Monday, October 13, 2008
What is it about Human Geography you're studying?
As for human geography, you're learning what cause humans to change a place. For example, a cultural geographer would attempt to understand how the culture of one person changes the place, and how a place can affect the culture of a person. A tourism geographer would attempt to understand how tourism cause people to change a place, and how a place can affect tourism. Hence, do understand how culture affects places, one must first understand the culture first, which is the job of anthropologist. For a tourism geographer to understand how tourism change places and vice-versa, he must first understand tourism well first, which is what tourism studies do.
Development geography and development studies are 2 different fields. Development studies are only concerned with how to make development better. They are people who try to find ways to improve education level, improve health, sanitation etc.
However, a development geographer sees development in a different way. Firstly, a development geographers study how development affect places and its distribution. Next, development geographers study how places affect development. Hence, to a geographer, the reason why a place has low level of development is not just because of low education level, poor sanitation etc. But rather, it is a result of its relationship with another place. For example, a periphery is less developed than the core because of its relationship. A colony is less developed than its colonial master because of their relationship between the 2 places. BUT a development geographer must first understand development first, before he or she can understand how it change places, and vice-versa. That is why you had to study how development is measured at the beginning.
As for food geographers, we do not see food as a innocent thing. Food is not just something that is consumed for nutrition purposes. Rather, food has the power to change and affect places, and conversely, places can change how food is produced, distributed and consumed.
For example, you've learn why food consumption and preferences have changed due to changes in food production, and how the distribution of this pattern have changed. You have also learnt how one place can change the food produced in another place. For example, why is Singapore importing seafood from an African country? Why is that country producing seafood in the first place? How does them producing seafood for Singapore change their landscape?
However, to be able to understand how food change places and vice-versa, you have to first understand what food is all about. Hence, you learnt concepts that seem to be from Food and Nutrition, such as staples, calories, etc.
Congrats!
Ok, stop complaining how you're not really graduated as you have to return to school.
But it is more of a symbolic end to a phase of your life.
Here's one song that's rather popular when I was graduating from secondary school(it's only 7 years ago. I'm not that old!). Think it's pretty meaningful for you all.
When you look back in your life,
about your secondary school days,
what will stick out is not the grades nor the homework,
but the relationships.
your relationships with your friends,
your relationships with your teachers,
your relationships with your b*******d/g********d
Graduation (by Vitamin C)
The Problem with Cumulative Causation
First, cumulative causation is under economic factors that lead to UNEVEN DEVELOPMENT. Hence, cumulative causation is suppose to explain WHY one place is MORE DEVELOPED than the other.
There are 2 popular definitions of cumulative causation.
The first definition is the one given by your textbook, which is how the start of one industry leads to a chain of other events, which leads to the creation of more industries, and the cycle is repeated, leading to more development. (http://www.answers.com/topic/cumulative-causation)
This definition is popularly used by economists. It does explain why a place becomes more developed, but it does not explain WHY there is uneven development between 2 places.
The 2nd definition, which is used in the notes, is more frequently used by geographers. It is an expansion from the first definition, but with some difference. The essence of the 2nd definition is as follows - cumulative causation is a process where an economic activity at the core leads to the core becoming more developed (this is where the first definition stops) than the periphery, by draining resources and labour from the periphery (adapted from Royal Geographic Society: http://www.geographyinthenews.rgs.org/glossary/?word=cumulative%20causation)
Hence, the notes used the 2nd definition, as that definition of cumulative causation explains WHY one place (the core) is more developed than the other (the periphery), which was the reason why you all learnt cumulative causation - to explain why there is uneven development. Also, in this way, it is easier to tie in the concept of spread effect and backwash.
Sunday, October 12, 2008
Coastal Management Techniques
The traditional 'hard' defence is the sea wall.In the past sea walls were vertical and deflected the energy of the waves away from the coast.
In doing so, however, they suffered a lot of expensive damage in a short period of time.
Modern sea walls have a slope and curved top which breaks up the energy of the wave and prevents water going over the top of the wall during heavy storms. Sea walls are very expensive (£2000-£5000 per metre) but should last 20-30 years.
A breakwater is often used to protect a harbour but may be used to protect a stretch of coastline. They are usually made of concrete or blocks of stone but recent cheaper alternative suggestions have included oil drums and used tyres. They have to be strong enough to take the full force of the waves. Since they have to be built in deep water they are, like sea walls, expensive to build.
The best form of natural defence is a beach which efficiently absorbs the energy of the waves. Along many coasts, however, longshore drift causes the beach to thin out in places and erosion of the land behind becomes a problem. Groynes are designed to slow down longshore drift and build up the beach. They are usually made of tropical hardwoods which are more resistant to marine borers and erosion. A few are made of concrete, steel or in more recent times large rocks. They are built at right angles to the shore and spaced about 50-100 metres apart. Groynes may have a life of 15-20 years but often have to be replaced rather than repaired.
A cheaper alternative to sea walls is the revetment (about £1200 per metre). This is a sloping feature which breaks up or absorbs the energy of the waves but may let water and sediment pass through. The older wooden revetment consists of posts fixed into the beach with wooden slats between. Modern revetments have concrete or shaped blocks of stone laid on top of a layer of finer material. Rock armour or riprap consists of layers of very hard rock with the largest, often weighing several tonnes, on the top. Riprap has the advantage of good permeability plus it looks more natural.
The gabion is a metal cage filled with rocks, about 1 metre by 1 metre square. They are stacked to form a simple wall. They are used to protect a cliff or area in the short term only, since they are easily damaged by powerful storm waves and the cages tend to rust quite quickly. Gabions have the advantage of ease of use and are relatively cheap but their life span is short.
Where longshore drift is a serious problem and the supply of beach material is poor, it may be necessary to supplement the natural system by adding lorry loads of sand and shingle to the beach. The natural processes will then spread the material along the coast to help build up the natural defences. This is called beach nourishment. Sometimes dredgers may be anchored offshore and the sediment sprayed on to the beach using high pressure hoses.
Application on Coastal management
This set was taken at Changi Ferry Point where we take a bum boat to Pulau Ubin
What are these structure called?
Why are they built?The traditional 'hard' defence is the sea wall.
Sea walls were vertical and deflected the energy of the waves away from the coast.
In doing so, however, they suffered a lot of expensive damage in a short period of time.
Sea walls are very expensive but should last 20-30 years.
This set of pictures were taken at the Singapore Sailing Centre
What is this structure called?
Close up view of the structure..jpg)
Another view of the structureRecap
A breakwater is often used to protect a harbour but may be used to protect a stretch of coastline.
They are usually made of concrete or blocks of stone but recent cheaper alternative suggestions have included oil drums and used tyres.
They have to be strong enough to take the full force of the waves.
Since they have to be built in deep water they are, like sea walls, expensive to build.
Access the effectiveness of using breakwater as a form of coastal management.
This set of pictures were taken when I went for the Sce 2 Camp at the camp cantre in East Coast.
What are these structure call?
This is how they are made at the beach..jpg)
Notice how a simpel chicken wire mash is made into a box?.jpg)
.jpg)
Rocks are then filled up and place at the beeach where protection are needed.
.jpg)
Recap
The gabion is a metal cage filled with rocks, about 1 metre by 1 metre square.
They are stacked to form a simple wall.
They are used to protect a cliff or area in the short term only, since they are easily damaged by powerful storm waves and the cages tend to rust quite quickly.
Gabions have the advantage of ease of use and are relatively cheap but their life span is short.
http://www.georesources.co.uk/leld.htm
- Land and sea meet along the coastline.
- The coast is shaped mainly by the action of the waves which reach the shore.
- Waves are created by the winds which blow across the surface.
- Friction results in the transfer of energy from the wind to the waves.
- The size of the waves depends on three factors:
- the strength of the wind
- the length of time that the wind blows
- the distance over which the wind blows [the fetch]
- The most common direction in which the waves move is determined by the prevailing winds i.e. the direction from which the winds blow most often.
- A wave will break when it reaches shallow water. As the water rushes up the beach it forms the swash and as it returns down the beach, the backwash.
- Some waves build up beach material [constructive waves] whilst others drag sand and pebbles down the beach [destructive waves].
- Waves erode or wear away the coast and transport the eroded material along the coastline - a process called longshore drift.
- Eventually the material will be deposited on a beach or will form a larger feature such as a spit.
- Erosion works in four ways:
- Hydraulic action - this results from the force of the water hitting the cliffs.
- Corrasion - this is caused by the waves picking up stones and hurling them at the cliffs.
- Attrition - any material carried by the waves will become rounder and smaller over time.
- Corrosion [solution] - the dissolving of rocks by sea water.

The nature of a coastline is often determined by its geology. Some coastlines are very dramatic, with tall, vertical cliffs whilst others are low-lying or marshy. Some coastlines are straight for miles and miles whilst others are indented with many headlands and bays.Long, fairly straight coastlines result where the rocks are very similar or just one type. If there are many rock-types and they vary in their resistance to erosion, then headlands and bays will form.
Many areas have cliffed coastlines. The nature of the cliff again depends on the geology of the rocks. Hard, resistant rocks form tall cliffs with a jagged upper section and a smoothed wave-cut notch at the base. If the rocks have many joints(vertical cracks) then erosion will be greater at some points and a cave may form. As the waves erode back into the cliff, the upper section becomes unstable and eventually collapses. In time the material from the cliff will be eroded into smaller and smaller pieces to form new beach material.If the rocks are soft, particularly clays, then the cliffs will be lower, caves rarely form and landslips may be common.
Beach material almost always moves along the beach in a particular direction which is determined by the prevailing winds. If the winds blow the waves parallel to the shore, sand and pebbles are washed up and back down the beach. If, however, the wind blows so that waves come in at a sharp angle to the coast, the swash carries the pebbles at an angle up the beach. When the backwash moves by gravity back down the beach, the pebbles end up at a different position. This process is repeated and pebbles gradually shift along the beach, a process called longshore drift.If the coastline has well developed headlands and bays, the headlands often show a variety of erosional landforms. Joints in the headlands are eroded back to form caves which over time are further eroded to form arches. The gaps in the headlands eventually collapse and leave tall stacks at the ends of the headlands. The stacks continue to be eroded by the waves until only stumps are left and these eventually disappear altogether.

Go here to see the coastal management technique
http://www.georesources.co.uk/coastman.htm
Questions on River and Coast
(i) Identify the two coastal landforms labelled X and Y in Figure 1. [2]
(ii) With the help of well-labelled diagrams, describe how the landforms above are formed. [6]
(b) Suggest why some parts of a coastline are always hit by powerful waves and how these coasts are able to withstand such powerful waves. [5]
(c) Using Figures 2 and 3, identify Structures A and B and describe how the structures can protect the coast from erosion. [6]
1. (a) Study Figure 1 below which shows a section of coastline in Australia.
(i) Identify the two coastal landforms labelled X and Y in Figure 1.
X = Headland
Y = Bay
(ii) With the help of well-labelled diagrams, describe how the landforms above are formed. [6]
1. coasts are made up of rocks with different resistance to erosion
2. less resistant rocks are eroded faster than more resistant rocks
3. different rates of erosion produces an uneven coastline
4. less resistant areas of rocks curve inwards as they get eroded away, forming bays
5. areas made of more resistant rocks will protrude out from the coastline, forming headlands
*Award a max of 3m for answers without diagrams.
(b) Suggest why some parts of a coastline are always hit by powerful waves and how these coasts are able to withstand such powerful waves.
1. if the coast faces a very long fetch or a large expanse of ocean, there will be powerful waves.
2. they are able to withstand powerful waves because they are made of hard resistant rocks eg. Granite.
3. it will take a long time to erode such resistant igneous rocks.
4. if the coast is sheltered, there will be few lines of weaknesses.
5. when seawalls and breakwaters are built, wave erosion is reduced too. If there are no strong prevailing winds, wave erosion is reduced too.
(c) Using Figures 2 and 3, identify Structures A and B and describe how the structures can protect the coast from erosion. [6]
1. structure A is a breakwater
2. it is built parallel to the coast but at some distance away to break the force of the incoming waves
3. it creates a zone of sheltered water behind it so that beaches can build up behind it
4. structure B is an artificial coral reef
5. they protect beaches by reducing the speed of the waves approaching the coast
6. thus, by the time the waves reach the shore, most of their energy would have been lost
(d) The construction of seawalls is a common coastal protection scheme used by many countries to protect their coastal areas. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using a seawall to prevent coastal erosion. [6]
Level 1 (states advantages and/or disadvantage ) 1-2m
- a seawall is strong and can last long
- it is expensive to construct and maintain
Level 2 (describe one or two advantages OR one or two disadvantages) 3-4m
- a seawall is usually made of granite and is strong enough to protect the coast against strong waves
- as it absorbs the energy of the waves.
Level 3 (describes at least two advantages AND disadvantages) 5-6m
- a seawall is a short-term solution
- as waves break against the seawall, the energy from the waves is redirected downwards at the base of the seawall
- it causes the seawall to weaken and eventually collapse
- it needs careful maintenance and regular repair
- it is expensive to build
Some pictures of sea wall around the world


Question on River and Coast
(i) Identify two major river features shown on the map. (2)
(ii) Using evidence only from the map, explain two important uses of the river to the people living around it. [4]
(b) Figure 1 below shows a sketch of a river valley.
Figure 1
Using the sketch and studies you have made, describe the shape of the river channel and its gradient in the upper and lower course. [4]
(c) Briefly explain how the presence of vegetation affects the volume of water in a river and how roughness of a river channel affects the speed of the river. [6]
(d) (i) Name three measures that may be used in the management of river channels to reduce the problems of flooding. [3]
(ii) Discuss the effectiveness of the measures named in (c)(i) in the control of floods. [6]
Suggest Answer
1. (a) Study the Zambezi River found on the topographical map of Victoria Falls, Zimbabwe (1:25 000) carefully.
(i) Identify two major river features shown on the map. [2]
1. rapids (7613)
2. meanders (7912)
3. waterfall - Rainbow Falls (7918)
4. gorges - Second Gorge (eg 7817 )
(ii) Using evidence only from the map, explain two important uses of the river to the people living around it. [4]
1. tourist attraction
2. eg hotels along the river, network of transport; presence of town/city Victoria Falls Waterfall
3. recreational activities
4. eg chalets along the coast
5. domestic or commercial use
6. eg presence of pump houses (GS7718) to pump water from the river
(b) Figure 1 below shows a sketch of a river valley.
Using the sketch and studies you have made, describe the shape of the river channel and its gradient in the upper and lower course. [4]
1. In the upper course, the river channel tends to be narrow and deep
2. While the gradient is steep
3. In the lower course, the river channel tends to be wide and shallow
4. While the gradient is gentle
(c) Briefly explain how the presence of vegetation affects the volume of water in a river and how roughness of a river channel affects the speed of the river. [6]
Answers that only explain one factor are to be awarded a max of 3m.
Presence of vegetation
1. The presence of thick vegetation in a drainage basin will result in less surface runoff.
2. The vegetation cover intercepts much of the rain that falls and allows some of it to infiltrate into the soil.
3. The increase in infiltration of water also results in a longer lag time for the water to reach the river channel so the volume will be lower.
4. In contrast, in a drainage basin with little or no vegetation, a greater amount of surface runoff occurs as there is no interception of rain and little infiltration into the ground.
5. Therefore, rivers in drainage basins with little or no vegetation cover experience a more rapid increase in the water level.
Roughness of a river channel
6. Increased channel roughness increases the amount of resistance in the river.
7. More energy will be used to overcome the resistance and added friction.
8. The effect is a slowdown in the flow of water.
9. Little obstacles or low channel roughness will have lesser amount of resistance in the river.
10. River flow will be faster as lesser energy is used to overcome the minimal friction by the obstacles.
(d) (i) Name three measures that may be used in the management of river channels to reduce the problems of flooding. [3]
Any 3 of the following:
1. River channelisation / Re-alignment
2. River re-sectioning
3. Bank protection
4. Planting Mangroves
5. Stabilising sand dunes
6. Growing corals
(ii) Discuss the effectiveness of the measures named in (c)(i) in the control of floods. [6]
Level 1 (describe one or two measures, no comment on whether they are effective or not ) 1-2m
- rivers can be deepened using re-sectioning or building bank protection.
Level 2 (describe one or two measures and briefly explain how effective they are in reducing floods) 3-4m
- re-sectioning is done by deepening a river using dredging.
- this is done to prevent the river water from reaching flood height and are generally effective.
Level 3 (describe two or three measures and explain effectiveness clearly with reference to positive and negative effects) 5-6m
- re-alignment helps to straighten the river channel
- it increases the speed of flow which will prevent the water from ever reaching flood height.
- it is an effective long-term measure.
- however, a lot of resources and manpower are required to carry them out.
Question on River and Coast
1(a) The diagram shows differences in the speed of flow of water in a river channel along a straight part of a river’s course (Click to see a bigger picture)
(i) Describe and explain the differences in the speed of flow
A) from the river bank to the middle of the river channel at the surface (from X to Y) [5]
B) from the surface of the river channel to the river bed near the middle of the river (from Y to Z) [4]
(ii) Explain how the speed of flow in a meander channel might differ from that shown in the diagram above and state the resulting features at the meander sides. [6]
(ii) Explain how the speed of flow in a meander channel might differ from that shown in the diagram above and state the resulting features at the meander sides. [6]
1b. Figs A and B show a section of coastline before coastal defences were built and after coastal defences were built.
(i) Describe the coastal section shown in Fig A and explain how it was affected by natural processes. [4]
(ii) Evaluate the success of the coastal defences shown along this section of the coastline as shown in Fig B. [6]
Suggested Answers
Suggested Answers
1(a) The diagram shows differences in the speed of flow of water in a river channel along a straight part of a river’s course.
(i) Describe and explain the differences in the speed of flow
A) from the river bank to the middle of the river channel at the surface (from X to Y) [5]
1. the speed of flow is slowest at the river bank (X)
2. because of friction with the sides
3. the speed of flow becomes faster towards the
middle of the channel (Y)
4. because the channel at the centre is deep
5. so there is less friction
B) from the surface of the river channel to the river bed near the middle of the river (from Y to Z) [4]
1. at Y, which is near the surface of the middle of the
channel, the river flow is fastest
2. as there is no friction
3. on approaching the river bed at Z, the river speed
slows down
4. because there is increasing friction with the river bed
(ii) Explain how the speed of flow in a meander channel might differ from that shown in the diagram above and state the resulting features at the meander sides. [6]
1. in a meander channel, the river bends
2. as the river water flows downstream and round a bend, the
force and hence speed of flow is greatest at the concave
bank (outer bank)
3. this will give rise to river cliffs
4. the force of water is furthest from the convex bank so the
speed of flow is slowest at the convex bank (inner bank)
5. this will give rise to slip-off slopes
6. hence the fastest flow is at the concave bank of a
meander and not in the centre as shown in the diagram above
(i) Describe the coastal section shown in Fig A and explain how it was affected by natural processes. [4]
1. in fig A, a landslip has taken place
2. this is because the land has poor drainage due to the layer
of clay
3. the water cannot drain through the layer of clay and so
collects in the soil
4. eventually the weight of the water-logged soil causes it to
slump down
(ii) Evaluate the success of the coastal defences shown along this section of the coastline as shown in Fig B. [6]
Level 1 (briefly describes at least two measures taken without evaluation) 1-2m
- drain is constructed at the point where the layer of clay starts
- steel barrier is placed mid-way up the cliff
- trench filled with rocks is carved out at the foot of the cliff
- concrete posts are placed at the foot of the cliff
- wooden barriers (groynes) are laid at the shoreline
Level 2 (describes at least two in greater detail and attempts to evaluate) 3-4m
- drain is constructed at the point where the layer of clay starts so that it can drain off the water and the soil will not be water-logged
- steel barrier is placed mid-way up the cliff to hold the land back and prevent it from slipping
- trench filled with rocks is carved out at the foot of the cliff so that even if the land slips, the trench will contain it and the rocks will prevent the soil from slipping further (rocks provide resistance)
- concrete posts placed at the foot of the hill hold the soil in place as the posts have to be driven into the soil so they are a stabilizing force
- wooden barriers (groynes) laid at the shoreline slow down erosion from longshore drift so the soil at the bottom of the cliff is not washed away and this will prevent weakening of the base of the cliff
Level 3 (considers broader picture) 5-6m
- the coastal defences are strong and should hold the cliff in place
- but if rainfall is too heavy, there might be some landslip still as gravel and sand are small and loosely-held so they may just be washed down the cliff face, thus causing erosion and slumping
Saturday, October 11, 2008
cumulative causation? core? periphery?
1) Core-periphery is to DESCRIBE the relationship between two countries / places, not to explain why there is uneven development
Eg: I'm a teacher, you're a student. Teacher-student will be the terms used to DESCRIBE our relationship, but it doesn't explain why I have more authority over you.
2) Cumulative causation is the PROCESS that leads to the uneven development between core-periphery
In summary, cumulative causation is the process in which the core becomes more developed than the periphery, by draining resources and labour from the periphery. Hence, the process explains why core and periphery, starts from being equally developed, to the core becoming more developed than the periphery.
THEREFORE
It will be inaccurate to say, one place BECAME more developed than the other because of core-periphery relationship.
Rather, it will be more accurate to say that one place BECAME more developed than another due to cumulative causation.
However, you can use core-periphery relationship to explain why the periphery is KEPT less developed than the core. To explain HOW it becomes less developed than the core, it will be more accurate to say that it is because of the PROCESS of cumulative causation.
Friday, October 10, 2008
Question on Development Core- periphery relationship.
Based on Table 1, explain why Australia is more developed than Nigeria. [5]
• Australia’s GDP per capita is higher at US$ 30677 than Nigeria’s US$835.
• This shows that the average income of the citizen in Australia is much higher than Nigeria. With the higher income, the people have a higher purchasing power and can afford to ulfil their needs and attain a higher standard of living. Higher purchasing power—> able to afford more goods and serives.
• Australia has a higher literacy rate of 99% than Nigeria’s 14.4%.
• This indicates that Australia is more developed than Nigeria because the government in Australia can provide the people with education. With higher education citizens are more efficient and productive
• More likely to work in the secondary and tertiary industries the people can have better jobs and earn higher income
• Nigeria has a Human Development Index value of 0.281 while Australia has a HDI value of 0.955. The closer the index is to 1, the higher the level of development. It is a holistic assessment of development. From the table, it can be seen that Australia has a much higher HDI than Nigeria, indicating that it is more developed than Nigeria.
• Life expectancy refers to the average number of years a person is expected to live. A developed country usually has a higher life expectancy than a less developed country. Nigeria’s life expectancy is 44.4 years old while Australia’s life expectancy is 80.3 years old.
• higher life expectancy is an indication that people live in a clean environment, have better access to health care, have enough food to eat higher standard of living.
• Answers can also accept other national measures to improve social well being such as improving education, sanitation facilities and eradicate slum
• However answers should not include economic measures to improve industrialisation
• Details should be pertaining to India and China
Level 1 ( 0 – 3 marks)
One or two general statements about the measures taken, eg. The China government introduced the one child policy
No assessment of how effective measures are
No supported effectiveness or simple statements, eg. it worked, it helped the poor people to improve their standard of living
Level 2 ( 4 – 6 marks)
Max 4m for one sided perspective view
Description of at least 3 Measures
Answer may have depth over a very narrow area, or have little detail but may touch on many relevant points
Brief statements of effectiveness
Level 3 ( 7 - 8 marks)
Well explained Measures/ methods of addressing social needs of people with details pertaining to China and India
There should be a balance of measures to weigh the success and failures the measures
A clear indication of effectiveness
1.d. With reference to example (s), assess the effectiveness of strategies to alleviate uneven development on an international scale among developed and undeveloped countries (7)
Candidates may include the following material:
International strategies to alleviate uneven development
- international cooperation
- international organisation
- World Bank
- Asian Development Bank
- International agreements
- United Nations Millennium Development Goals
-United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea
International organisations:
• The World Bank funds the Kecamatan Development Programme, which helps to reduce poverty in Sleepy Tirtomoyo, Indonesia
• Provided financial and technical support to villagers in Sleepy Tirtomoyo
• The financial aid enables the locals to dig wells to tap on underground water source and build pipelines so as to provide water supply to homes
• Kecamatan Development programme gives villagers the empowerment to utilise the funds on the basis of their needs and priorities thus reducing poverty
• The Asian Development Bank funds the Jamuna’s Multipurpurpose Bridge Project in Bangladesh that aims to improve the country’s transport infrastructure
• The bridge connects Bangladesh’s less developed northwestern region to its more developed eastern region
• Provided financial and technical support to construct the bridge that has roads, railway, gas pipelines and telecommunication lines
• Encourages economic growth in less developed northwestern region by increasing passenger and goods traffic
• Improved living conditions through improved infrastructure and removing existing traffic congestion
• Bridge connects agricultural areas of Dhaka and the port of Chittagong, making it easier for farmers to transport their produce to the markets for sale
International Agreements
• United Nations Millennium Development Goals target at reducing poverty by achieving greater development in the less developed countries such as in Vietnam
• Provides training for people living in poor communities to equip them with skills and knowledge to look for jobs
• They can afford basic necessities and improve their standard of living when they have a steady source of income
• Increase the access to basic social services for the poor
• Carry out educational campaigns to raise awareness of the dire situation of poverty in the country and exert pressure on the government to create more jobs and increase rural income
• Increase primary education for everyone in the world
• Increase enrollment in schools
• United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea helps to control the usage of resources in the seas and oceans
• Expensive and advanced equipment in the larger fishing boats from DCs enables them to spot fishes easily and compete with the poor fishermen from Peru
• Establish an Economic Exclusive Zone
• Ensure that the fishermen in the LDCs can have access to good fish stock despite not having high-tech fishing vessels
A full answer does not need to include all the above points
Level 1 ( 0 – 3 marks)
One or two statements about measures taken, eg. World Bank & Asian Development Bank gives financial assistance to LEDCs
No assessment of how effective measures are
No supported effectiveness or simple statements , eg. it worked, it helped the poor people to improve their standard of living
Level 2 ( 4 – 6 marks)
Measures need to be specific, eg. World Bank provides KDP with funds to improve sanitation & water supply; ; ADB provide Vietnam with financial and technical assistance in the urban areas
Limited indication of how well people cope/ how effective measures are. Eg. Their standard of living improves as there is now proper irrigation….
Answer may have depth over a very narrow area, or have little detail but may touch on many relevant points
Brief statements of effectiveness
Level 3 ( 7 - 8 marks)
Measures/ methods of alleviating uneven development needed with detail
There should be a balance of measures to weigh the success and failures of both International cooperation
Clear statements of how well these measures help people cope needed
A clear indication of effectiveness
International Cooperation may not be the one and only measure to alleviate uneven development; different countries have different sets of problems which can be solved through National Strategies such as population policy etc
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
Question on Development
(b) Explain how cumulative causation affects development in core areas. [4]
(c) Discuss how education affects the development of a country. [4]
(d) Suggest reasons why it is difficult to use various indicators to make an accurate comparison of the level of development between any two countries. [4]
(e) Read the extract below by an environmental activist, and assess the feasibility of organic farming replacing “modern farming methods” in the long term. [8]
With reference to Fig 1A, describe the relationship between the availability of natural resources in a country and its GDP per capita. [5 marks]
• Based on Fig 1, there is no direct or distinct relationship between the availability of natural resources in a country and its GDP per capita.
• Among the four countries, Brazil has the most natural resources, but has the lowest GDP per capita of US$8 600.
• On the other hand, Singapore has no natural resources, but has the second highest GDP per capita at US$30 000.
• This does not mean that there is an inverse relationship between the availability of natural resources in a country and GDP per capita, as Norway is well-endowed with many natural resources, and boasts the highest GDP per capita among the four countries.
• This could suggest that countries need to utilise their natural resources well in order to boost their economy and GDP per capita, and that there are also other factors affecting GDP per capita.
(1 mark for one point above, accept any other plausible answer)
b. Explain how cumulative causation affects development in core areas. [4 marks]

• The process of how the movement of people and resources from a periphery area increases the wealth of a core area is known as cumulative causation.
• A core area attracts workers from the periphery area, as the core often receives new investments for development of industries, and creates more employment.
• As more people live and work in the core area, there is an increased demand for goods and services.
• With increased demand, the core area would draw further investments, leading to the expansion of existing industries and the establishment of new businesses. As more jobs are generated, the general wealth of the people living in the core increases as well. This helps to raise the level of development of the core.
(1 mark for one point above, accept any other plausible answer)
(c) Discuss how education affects the development of a country. [4 marks]
• Education, measured in terms of literacy rate, often determines the types of industries a country’s population can work in. With more people in the country being able to read and write, they have the capability and required skills to work in the secondary and tertiary industries, which contribute more to a country’s GDP.
• On the other hand, low literacy rate in a country would mean that a high proportion of its population is unskilled and only able to work in primary industries such as agriculture, which generate less income.
• With a workforce that has a high literacy rate, a country is more likely to attract foreign investors that employ skilled workers, thus driving the development of the country.
• Education may also play a part in other areas affecting development. For example, people who receive education may be more knowledgeable about the importance of sanitation or infant care. This helps to raise their standard of living, reduce infant mortality, and improve the country’s overall level of development.
(1 mark for one point above, accept any other plausible answer)
(d) Suggest reasons why it is difficult to use various indicators to make an accurate comparison of the level of development between two countries.
[4 marks]
• Different countries may interpret indicators differently. For example, when collecting data on literacy rate, countries may differ on the level of education a person has before he or she is considered literate.
• There may be problems gathering a complete set of data in certain countries. It may be easier to collect data from a country with a highly urbanised population, as compared to a country where many rural areas may be inaccessible or too sparsely populated to gather data accurately.
• When comparing GDP or GDP per capita, it should be noted that the data does not include income generated in the informal sectors. Hence, a country with a low GDP per capita may not truly reflect a low level of development, as its people may be greatly involved in these informal sectors.
• Sometimes, data might be obtained from different sources at different time periods. Hence, data collection or calculation methods may differ from country to country, and data may be more up-to-date in some countries than others.
(1 mark for one point above, accept any other plausible answer)
(e) Read the quote below by an environmental activist, and assess the feasibility of organic farming replacing “modern farming methods” in the long term. [8 marks]
Today’s modern farming methods are destructive to both man and nature, and should no longer be carried out further. Organic farming is a more environmentally sustainable system over the long term.
• For example, the use of chemical fertilisers, pesticides and herbicides may lead to environmental effects such as water pollution and destruction of animal life. In addition, they may also be harmful to the health of consumers, as strains of these chemicals may be found in the food that is produced.
• GM food also contains risks such as the loss of natural species if GM crops genetically pollute natural crops. Potential health hazards are also possible if the food contains genes or substances that are harmful to humans.
• Organic farming minimises these risks, as they practice farming methods that do not use chemicals or GM crops.
• For example, instead of using chemical fertilisers, organic farmers make use of animal manure as fertiliser. They also rear natural predators to pests, instead of spraying pesticides on crops that may end up polluting water bodies or being consumed by man. They also practise crop rotation so as to keep the soil fertile over a long period.
• If current farming methods are employed, the environment may not be sustainable as more and more pollution occurs. By replacing these practises with organic farming, both man and nature would benefit in the long term.
• However, there are several limitations of organic farming that must be overcome if it was to be feasible. As the world’s population grows, the demand of food is ever increasing. Organic farming practises may not be able to produce enough quantity of food to supply the world’s population.
• As organic farming methods require higher costs, these costs would also be transferred to the consumers, thus making food more expensive. This would greatly affect consumers, especially those in less developed countries (LDCs), since they may not be able to afford expensive organic food products. More people may go hungry and suffer from starvation as a result.
Monday, October 6, 2008
Question on Development Case study of Ghana, Thailand, India and Bangladesh
i. What do you understand by this term ‘income per capita’? [2]
ii. With reference to examples, explain why income per capita should not be the only indicator to measure the development of a country. [4]
(b) The table below shows development issues in Ghana.
Life in Ghana today:
- Politically stable
- Need US$6 Billion to develop infrastructur
- GNI is US$477 per capita
- Highly dependent on aid
- Common for people to love with no electricity that produces hydroelectric power.
- Almost all electricity generated sold to aluminum smelters and process of electricity are high
- Most people work in informal sector and never declare income 70% are farmers but still imports food
- Export cocoa beans to UK
- People commonly go hungry and families rarely eat meat.
- 3 buckets of water per day cost 10-20% of average daily income of 1 person
- One of the best schools in Ghana has fees of US$600/year.
i. Suggest why Ghana faces difficulty in developing its economy. [6]
ii. Using the problems identified in (i), explain what the Ghanaian government can do to increase the standard of living. [5]
(c) With reference to studies made, evaluate the success of strategies used
by governments in Less Developed Countries to promote national
development in education, health and the economy. [8]
As usual try to attempt the question first before looking at the answer.
1 (a) i. What do you understand by this term ‘income per capita’?
- Average income each worker in a country receives in a year
- Indicator of wealth of people in a country and the standard of living
- Take the total income of a country divide by total population
- Examples of measurements would be gross domestic product per capita or gross national product per capita [2]
ii. With reference to examples, explain why income per capita should not be the
only indicator to measure the development of a country.
- Indicates only the average income earned per person, will not know the
income gap in the country - Countries like China and India may appear to have lower gdp/capita but
there are extremely rich pp. (big / wide y distribution) - Rural poor, urban migrant workers vs. small % of urban rich
- Limited in showing social development / quality of living especially in education and health e.g Middle Eastern countries … rich because of production of oil but education and health
- Infrastructure not comparable to income per capita. e.g Singapore … high income per capita but not considered developed in terms of % of population with tertiary education, lagging behind DCs such as USA and Japan. [4]
(b) Fig. 1 shows development issues in Ghana.
(i) Suggest why Ghana faces difficulty in developing its economy. [6]
- Low income per capita (US$477) = government has little revenue to develop country and need US$6b to develop infrastructure
- Highly dependent on aid = in debt (not all aid are free)
- Poorly developed infrastructure : water supply, education, electricity supply
- Income gap between rich and poor is wide, most are poor farmers
- 70% are farmers but there is insufficient food
- agric products are cash crops, low value.
- Agriculture are exported without processing
- public utilities such as water supply is barely existent… and expensive.Had to buy buckets from water vendors, 20% of income
- there is electricity but not for the population, channeled for mining and smelting.
- Schools are not readily available and accessible except to the very rich … high school fees of US$600 per year.
If only cut and paste info from the table, max 3m.
(ii) Using the problems identified in (i), explain what the Ghanaian
government can do to increase the standard of living. [5]
- Add value to agric products such as cocoa beans like process them into cocoa powder
- Overtime, manufacture chocolate
- Diversify in to food crops that can meet population’s needs, cheaper than importing food.
- Plant GM food / HYVs, fertilizers etc to increase yields especially food crops, sell/export surplus
- Mechanize farming
- All these measures will reduce aid and dependency on imported food and yet earn revenue from export.
- Use political stability to set up tax system to collect more revenue.
- Reduce reliance on foreign aid This source of income can be used to develop infrastructure public utilities, proper public water services and supply, electricity supply and education facilities.
- Add value to al by processing them into steel.
- Create employment for population, higher salary than working as a miner.
(d) With reference to studies made, evaluate the success of strategies used by
governments in Less Developed Countries to promote national development
in education, health and the economy. [8]
L1 0-3
Describe strategies only. Brief statements on success. Country example only.
L2 – 4-6
Must have evaluation of success, specific egs to get highest of L2.
4m Covers 1 in depth
5m Covers 2 in depth
6m Covers 2 in depth, 1 superficially
L3 – 7-8 Covers all 3, clear evaluation and specific egs.
Education
Thailand’s hill tribe community project in 1998
77 established in 1998 under government’s policy to provide, ‘Education for All’
Formal and non-formal education programmes developed to suit needs of communities, eg
i. Academic subjects and life skills taught
ii. Sustainable farming methods taught to local farmers
Result
i. Many are able to obtain employment in cities
ii. Agricultural production increased
iii. General increase in income has helped in improving the standard of living of the people in the country.
Constrains
i. BUT depends on availability of volunteer teachers from more developed region teach in community learning centre.
ii. Communication barriers.. strong culture
iii. Adaptability to changes by the hill tribe. Resistance to formal education,
iv. suspicious of westerners from NGOs.
v. Geographically isolated, poor transport and accessibility.
vi. Difficult for government to reach out to all and attract volunteers
vii. Politically unstable area, Myanmar and Thai border, danger element and instability o livelihood.
Health (water supply and sanitation facilities)
Case of Ahmedabad in Gujarat, India
· Parivartan Slum Networking Programme
· Aims to help region develop by improving lives of slum dwellers
· Site and Services Scheme (new housing site).
· Provision of basic infrastructure: water supply and underground sewerage
· Supported by local government, funded by local banks
· Monthly monitoring meetings, future planning sessions
· Training sessions on proper use of facilities
· Benefited 56,000 people in >40 slums/squatters
· Expanded to include 59 more slums
·
Results
o Death rates declined from 6.9 per 1,000 people to 3.7 per 1,000 people
o Fewer people falling ill, Increased standard of living, Helped region to develop.
Problems
o Slum dwellers unwilling to move should they have to shift out to an improved area.
o Could be at the fringe of the city, far away from the workplace, too lowly paid to afford transport despite better water supply and sanitation facilities, jobs in the city centre
o Culture and tradition, generations have been there.
o Economy by creating jobs and financial assistance
Economic Growth
“Linking Arms Against Poverty” OR Grameen Microfinancing in Bangladesh
· Aims to increase employment rate and income of the poor
· Benefit
o Resources provided to informal sector
o Government works with NGOs to assess viability to business ventures before loans are offered.
o Microfinance, or small loans, were given to small businesses
o Ultra-poor given interest free loans
o Programme supported by several other NGOs and private organizations
o Poor given training and advice to run businesses effectively 600,000 agricultural jobs created in rural areas, 3 million businesses assisted,1.7 million provided employment through job placement schemes.
Problems
o Income gap still very wide bet rich and poor.
o Little access to markets to sell their products which are usually handicraft.
o Insufficient volunteers in the microfinance programme to give loans, provide training, reach out to the more enterprising poor especially in isolated areas.
Sunday, October 5, 2008
How NOT to answer a question
Background information
The US$700 billion bailout plan is basically a financial plan by the US government to spent US$700 billion on helping banks and financial institutions recover their losses(which they created), if not, which might cause a worldwide financial crisis.
Question:
Why isn’t it better, Governor Palin, to spend $700 billion helping middle-class families struggling with health care, housing, gas and groceries? … Instead of helping these big financial institutions that played a role in creating this mess?
Answer
PALIN: Ultimately, what the bailout does is help those who are concerned about the health care reform that is needed to help shore up the economy– Oh, it’s got to be about job creation too. So health care reform and reducing taxes and reining in spending has got to accompany tax reductions.
Mistakes made
1) Links are not clearly Elaborated.
eg: how is does the bailout plan leads to helping those concerned with healthcare? (and job creation. What has reducing taxes got to do with all these by the way(and then to trade....wait...how does all these link to the bailout plan?)
2) Evidence?
3) Did not Link back to the question
(the question was more of about why it is better to spend money on those financial institutions instead of helping people cope with the cost of living?)
Our Chicken comes from Brazil???
Friday, October 3, 2008
read this article by a Muslim published in The News the Internet edition of The News International newspaper with the latest stories from Pakistan.
By: Dr. Farrukh Saleem*
Why are Jews so powerful?
There are only 14 million Jews in the world; seven million in the Americas, five million in Asia, two million in Europe and 100,000 in Africa. For every single Jew in the world there are 100 Muslims.
Yet, Jews are more than a hundred times more powerful than all the Muslims put together. Ever wondered why?
Jesus of Nazareth was Jewish. Albert Einstein, the most influential scientist of all time and TIME magazine’s ‘Person of the Century’, was a Jew. Sigmund Freud — id, ego, superego — the father of psychoanalysis was a Jew. So were Karl Marx, Paul Samuelson and Milton Friedman.
Here are a few other Jews whose intellectual output has enriched the whole humanity:
- Benjamin Rubin gave humanity the vaccinating needle.
- Jonas Salk developed the first polio vaccine.
- Alert Sabin developed the improved live polio vaccine.
- Gertrude Elion gave us a leukaemia fighting drug. Baruch Blumberg developed the vaccination for Hepatitis B.
- Paul Ehrlich discovered a treatment for syphilis (a sexually transmitted disease).
- Elie Metchnikoff won a Nobel Prize in infectious diseases.
- Bernard Katz won a Nobel Prize in neuromuscular transmission.
- Andrew Schally won a Nobel in endocrinology (disorders of the endocrine system; diabetes, hyperthyroidism) .
- Aaron Beck founded Cognitive Therapy (psychotherapy to treat mental disorders, depression and phobias).
- Gregory Pincus developed the first oral contraceptive pill.
- George Wald won a Nobel for furthering our understanding of the human eye.
- Stanley Cohen won a Nobel in embryology (study of embryos and their development).
- Willem Kolff came up with the kidney dialysis machine.
Why are Jews so powerful?
- Stanley Mezor invented the first micro-processing chip.
- Leo Szilard developed the first nuclear chain reactor.
- Peter Schultz, optical fibre cable;
- Charles Adler, traffic lights;
- Benno Strauss, Stainless steel;
- Isador Kisee, sound movies;
- Emile Berliner, telephone microphone and
- Charles Ginsburg, videotape recorder.
Famous financiers in the business world who belong to Jewish faith include
- Ralph Lauren (Polo),
- Levis Strauss (Levi’s Jeans),
- Howard Schultz (Starbuck’s) ,
- Sergey Brin (Google),
- Michael Dell (Dell Computers),
- Larry Ellison (Oracle),
- Donna Karan (DKNY),
- Irv Robbins (Baskins & Robbins) and
- Bill Rosenberg (Dunkin Donuts).
- Richard Levin, President of Yale University, is a Jew.
- So are Henry Kissinger (American secretary of state),
- Alan Greenspan (fed chairman under Reagan, Bush, Clinton and Bush),
- Joseph Lieberman,
- Madeleine Albright (American secretary of state),
- Casper Weinberger (American secretary of defence),
- Maxim Litvinov (USSR foreign Minister),
- David Marshal (Singapore’s first chief minister),
- Issac Isaacs (governor-general of Australia),
- Benjamin Disraeli (British statesman and author),
- Yevgeny Primakov (Russian PM),
- Barry Goldwater,
- Jorge Sampaio (president of Portugal),
- John Deutsch(CIA director),
- Herb Gray (Canadian deputy PM),
- Pierre Mendes (French PM),
- Michael Howard (British home secretary),
- Bruno Kreisky (chancellor of Austria) and
- Robert Rubin (American secretary of treasury).
Can you name the most beneficent philanthropist in the history of the world?
The name is George Soros, a Jew, who has so far donated a colossal $4 billion most of which has gone as aid to scientists and universities around the world.
Second to George Soros is Walter Annenberg, another Jew, who has built a hundred libraries by donating an estimated $2 billion.
At the Olympics, Mark Spitz set a record of sorts by wining seven gold medals. Lenny Krayzelburg is a three-time Olympic gold medalist. Spitz, rayzelburg and Boris Becker are all Jewish.
Did you know that Harrison Ford, George Burns, Tony Curtis, Charles Bronson, Sandra Bullock, Billy Crystal, Woody Allen, Paul Newman, Peter Sellers, Dustin Hoffman, Michael Douglas, Ben Kingsley, Kirk Douglas, Goldie Hawn, Cary Grant, William Shatner, Jerry Lewis and Peter Falk are all Jewish?
As a matter of fact, Hollywood itself was founded by a Jew. Among directors and producers, Steven Spielberg, Mel Brooks, Oliver Stone, Aaron Spelling (Beverly Hills 90210), Neil Simon (The Odd Couple), Andrew Vaina (Rambo 1/2/3), Michael Man (Starsky and Hutch), Milos Forman (One flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest), Douglas Fairbanks (The thief of Baghdad) and Ivan Reitman (Ghostbusters) are all Jewish.
To be certain, Washington is the capital that matters and in Washington the lobby that matters is The American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC. Washington knows that if PM Ehud Olmert were to discover that the earth is flat, AIPAC will make the 109th Congress pass a resolution congratulating Olmert on his discovery.
William James Sidis, with an IQ of 250-300, is the brightest human who ever existed. Guess what faith did he belong to?
Question: So, why are Jews so powerful?
Answer: Education.
Why are Muslims so powerless?
There are an estimated 1,476,233,470 Muslims on the face of the planet: one billion in Asia, 400 million in Africa, 44 million in Europe and six million in the Americas. Every fifth human being is a Muslim; for every single Hindu there are two Muslims, for every Buddhist there are two Muslims and for every Jew there are one hundred Muslims.
Ever wondered why Muslims are so powerless?
Here is why: There are 57 member-countries of the Organisation of Islamic Conference (OIC), and all of them put together have around 500 universities; one university for every three million Muslims. The United States has 5,758 universities and India has 8,407. In 2004, Shanghai Jiao Tong University compiled an ‘Academic Ranking of World Universities’ , and intriguingly, not one university from Muslim-majority states was in the top-500.
As per data collected by the UNDP, literacy in the Christian world stands at nearly 90 per cent and 15 Christian-majority states have a literacy rate of 100 per cent.
A Muslim-majority state, as a sharp contrast, has an average literacy rate of around 40 per cent and there is no Muslim-majority state with a literacy rate of 100 per cent.
Some 98 per cent of the ‘literates’ in the Christian world had completed primary school, while less than 50 percent of the ‘literates’ in the Muslim world did the same.
Around 40 per cent of the ‘literates’ in the Christian world attended university while no more than two per cent of the ‘literates’ in the Muslim world did the same.
Muslim-majority countries have 230 scientists per one million Muslims. The US has 4,000 scientists per million and Japan has 5,000 per million.
In the entire Arab world, the total number of full-time researchers is 35,000 and there are only 50 technicians per one million Arabs (in the Christian world there are up to 1,000 technicians per one million).
Furthermore, the Muslim world spends 0.2 per cent of its GDP on research and development, while the Christian world spends around five per cent of its GDP.
Conclusion: The Muslim world lacks the capacity to produce knowledge.
Daily newspapers per 1,000 people and number of book titles per million are two indicators of whether knowledge is being diffused in a society.
In Pakistan, there are 23 daily newspapers per 1,000 Pakistanis while the same ratio in Singapore is 360. In the UK, the number of book titles per million stands at 2,000 while the same in Egypt is 20.
Conclusion: The Muslim world is failing to diffuse knowledge.
Exports of high technology products as a percentage of total exports are an important indicator of knowledge application. Pakistan’s exports of high technology products as a percentage of total exports stands at one per cent.
The same for Saudi Arabia is 0.3 per cent; Kuwait, Morocco, and Algeria are all at 0.3 per cent while Singapore is at 58 per cent.
Conclusion: The Muslim world is failing to apply knowledge.
Why are Muslims powerless? Because we aren’t producing knowledge.
Why are Muslims powerless? Because we aren’t diffusing knowledge.
Why are Muslims powerless? Because we aren’t applying knowledge.
And, the future belongs to knowledge-based societies.
Interestingly, the combined annual GDP of 57 OIC-countries is under $2 trillion. America, just by herself, produces goods and services worth $12 trillion; China $8 trillion, Japan $3.8 trillion and Germany $2.4 trillion (purchasing power parity basis).
Oil rich Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait and Qatar collectively produce goods and services (mostly oil) worth $500 billion; Spain alone produces goods and services worth over $1 trillion, Catholic Poland $489 billion and Buddhist Thailand $545 billion (Muslim GDP as a percentage of world GDP is fast declining).
So, why are Muslims so powerless?
Answer: Lack of education!
(The writer is an Islamabad-based freelance columnist. This article was published in The News)
Please note: (This is an article written by a Muslim with facts, figures and data provided to support his conclusion. This article is published in Parkistan.
Whta do I want you to learn?
Like social studies, if you make a claim, you must have the data to support your claim.
Like in Geography of development, education and knowledge based economy is the key to your future.)

